Home | Articles
Balanced Scorecard Design: Creating a Customer-centric Culture

by Bill Barberg

White Paper : The First Step to Superior Performance Management
Management and users demand that IT deliver 'a single version of the truth'. Enterprise reporting is a way out of this chaos. Download

If properly deployed, the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) can be a powerful tool to influence the behavior of people and the culture of an organization. Yet for many organizations, it is merely a half-hearted effort to include some non-financial measurements in their quarterly review process. Busy executive who may have initially generated some activity regarding the Balanced Scorecard can lose interest and shift to the next priority—such as customer relationship management (CRM) or trying to create a customer-focused culture. Too often, the BSC is then regarded just one of a series of “been there, done that” management fads—which is unfortunate, since the BSC could have been instrumental in helping accomplish many of those other priorities. This article focuses on how the BSC can play a valuable contributing role in creating a customer-centric culture and promote improved customer relationships.

Evaluating the Objectives in the Customer Perspective

When reviewing an organization’s Balanced Scorecard, one of the first questions I ask is: “Are the objectives and measures in your Customer Perspective really from the customer’s perspective?” It is common to find scorecard objectives such as “Improve profit per customer” and measures such as “Revenue per customer” in the customer perspective. While those measures certainly relate to the customer, they don’t answer the question that should be fundamental to this part of Balanced Scorecard design. The classic question for this perspective asks: “To achieve our vision, how should we appear to our customers?” Another way of characterizing the objectives for this perspective is to ask: “What is our differentiating value proposition for our targeted customers?” How often, when selecting a bank, hotel chain or health care provider, does a person think, “I want to find one that makes a lot of profit per customer”? Not too often. Those measures are not important from the customer’s perspective.

Furthermore, measures like “Profit per customer” do not contribute much to defining the strategy of an organization, so they provide little help in focusing resources on effectively executing that strategy, which is a key function of the Balanced Scorecard. The measures that end up on the scorecard (if you’re following the best practices of the Balanced Scorecard Collaborative or the Balanced Scorecard Institute) should reflect progress toward critical strategic objectives, which are selected based on how they collectively define a strategy and how that strategy can be implemented. Much of the benefit from the BSC methodology comes from the process of developing the BSC, not just the resulting scorecard. The BSC provides a common set of terminology and a conceptual framework that enables a much more efficient and effective discussion of an organization’s strategy. The critical thinking surrounding the strategy, objectives, measures and initiatives force an organization to address difficult—but very important—issues such as who are they targeting as their customer and what is the unique value proposition they are offering? Strategy gurus, such as Michael Porter, stress that strategy is largely about accomplishing more with less, and that requires focus. Determining what you are NOT is often more important then emphasizing what you ARE going to emphasize as an organization. Trying to be all things to all people is rarely a formula for success in today’s competitive landscape.

Resource Center
Business Intelligence
Oracle #1 in Business Analytics According to IDC Research
BI Search
The Business Intelligence Search Engine has all the answers.
Business Intelligence Search Engine
Find all you need on The Business Intelligence Search Engine.
Add a Link Add a Link

  
Other Articles by this Author

Balanced Scorecard Best Practices: Understanding Leading Measures

Building Roads: Getting to a Shared Understanding of BI Costs & Benefits

Pragmatic Business Intelligence and Scorecarding (Part 2)

Pragmatic Business Intelligence and Scorecarding (Part 1)

Correcting the Balanced Scorecard Metaphor. It’s much more than just a Dashboard

Structured versus Unstructured: Choices for Information Management

The Right Tool for the Task: Differences in Dealing with Structured versus Unstructured Information

Reinforcing a Customer-Centered Strategic Focus by Cascading a Balanced Scorecard

Balanced Scorecard Design: Creating a Customer-centric Culture

Business Intelligence and Balanced Scorecard: Different Paradigms

Misconceptions about the Balanced Scorecard





Designing and Implementing Business Intelligence Solutions Using Microsoft SQL Server. Click for details.
Business Intelligence Solution Finder

What do you need?

Location of solution provider

What type of solution are you interested in?

Are you interested in a specific solution?                      


All product names are trademarks of their respective companies.
Copyright © ITNetwork365 - All Rights Reserved